DeclineEvaluated

MILES GODALLE

Qualified Carpenter · latest application 2d ago

milesgodalle2@gmail.com

+63 9984343177

Evaluation

Confidence

high

Source

llm_claude

Version

Cost

$—

Miles is an experienced shipboard carpenter (yachts and passenger ships, 2009–2024) with maritime certifications and seamanship duties. There is zero residential carpentry experience on the CV — no architectural, high-end, or even low-rise residential work despite the Seek screening answer claiming low-rise experience (the CV does not support that claim). Kingston Construction hires premium architectural residential carpenters; this is a hard-rule automatic decline under Ry's tier classifier (purely non-residential background, no evidence of quality residential work). Compounding factors: requires sponsorship, no Australian driver's licence, no Construction Induction (white) card, and no cover letter was provided — so no signal of genuine interest in or knowledge of Kingston Construction. The CV is tidy and the candidate appears mature and stable, but the fundamental experience mismatch cannot be bridged at the application stage.

Findings (7)

communicationneutralminor

CV is clearly written, organised, free of typos. Objective statement is coherent if generic.

cover_letter_qualityred flagstrong

No cover letter was attached (cover_letter_attached: false). No reference to Kingston Construction, architectural carpentry, or why this role specifically.

quality_mindsetneutralminor

CV mentions 'Maintained interiors and cabins to high standards' and lists furniture fabrication, teak deck repair, varnishing — but no specifics on tolerances, builders, or architectural finish standards.

residential_experiencered flagcritical

Entire career (2009–2024) is shipboard carpentry on yachts (MY Azzam, 180m private yacht) and passenger ships (MV Ocean Dream, SS Oceanic). No residential project, builder, or architectural finish work mentioned anywhere.

screening_answer_inconsistencyred flagmoderate

Seek screening answer states 'Yes, I've worked on low rise construction projects' but the CV shows no land-based construction work at all — only shipboard roles.

tenure_stabilityneutralminor

Long-running relationship with MY Azzam (2013–2024 across multiple seasonal contracts). Earlier roles also multi-year. No job-hopping pattern.

work_rights_and_logisticsred flagstrong

Requires sponsorship to work in Australia. No Australian driver's licence. No Construction Induction (white) card. Based in the Philippines.

Applications

Qualified Carpenter

19 May, 10:37 pm · 19e422ec0800a4b3

Evaluated